Christopher was arrested in 2004 for unrelated charges, and in 2005 christine confessed to her husband during a murder anniversary retrospective that she had been the one to kill them. In 2006, a friend christine had confessed to called in a tip that resulted in warrants for both christine and christopher. Christopher committed suicide after learning of the warrant. In 2008, christine was sentenced to life in prison for the murders of adelbert, rachael, marcus, and tiffany.
The murders were committed with the assistance of her boyfriend , Christopher Snider and the case was named as Clear Lake murders. Christine Paolilla was sentenced to life with parole eligibility in 2046. By the time Paolilla was ready to enter high school, her mother had received the help she needed and was able to have custody of Christine and her brother again. The family moved to Clear Lake City, Texas and Paolilla attended Clear Lake High School. Rott said he and his wife were spending about $10,000 on drugs. The money being used was part of an inheritance Paolilla received after her father died in a construction accident when she was 4, Rott said.
Despite it all, Christine appeared to cling to the relationship. But on the afternoon of July 18, 2003, Christine’s life changed forever. Four youths were found shot multiple times at point blank range in a home in the placid Clear Lake neighborhood.
Rott testified that appellant admitted to beating Koloroutis with her gun until she was dead. Two eyewitnesses placed appellant at the scene of the crime. Michelle and Craig seekers nightmares Lackner lived next door to Tiffany Rowell. The Lackners testified that on the day of the offense, they both observed a young man and woman casually walk down the street and approach Rowell's house. In court, the Lackners identified appellant as the girl they had witnessed. They denied seeing her with a gun, but they each said that she was carrying a purse.
Paolilla's bail was set at $500,000 as she was considered a flight risk. On July 18, 2003, Paolilla and Snider went to her friend Tiffany Rowell's home in Clear Lake City. Also at the home were Rachael Koloroutis, Rowell's boyfriend Marcus Precella, and Precella's cousin Adelbert Sanchez. Rachael Koloroutis attempted to crawl to a phone to call 911 after she was shot but Paolilla struck her in the head multiple times with the butt of a 38-caliber revolver, bashing in her skull. Koloroutis and Rowell were both shot in the crotch, a sign of sexual jealousy. Snider and Paolilla left little evidence at the crime scene leading police to suspect that the killings were drug related as Marcus Precella was said that he sold drugs from the home.
She was arrested on July 19, 2006, three years and one day after the murders were committed. Paolilla was convicted in October 2008 and sentenced to life in prison. Snider committed suicide in July 2006 before he was apprehended by police. Finally, even if the prosecutor's argument did encourage the jury to speculate on facts not in the record, evidence of appellant's participation in the murders was already well-substantiated. For instance, the Lackners witnessed appellant casually approaching Rowell's house on the day of the murders. In her third recorded statement, appellant herself admitted to being inside the home and holding a gun as her boyfriend pulled the trigger.